Nov 29, 2013
Thanks for the comparison! The TV Reflections guide top choice is a plasma TV (ST60
). My understanding is that for a bright room with windows like mine, this model is the best choice, and better than any LED?
Not really. Yes, it has the least amount of reflection. However, there are two things to consider in a bright room: reflection and brightness. Plasmas (with the exception of the Samsung F8500
) don't get very bright (82 cd/m2
for the ST60
, compared to 300 cd /m2
for some LEDs). In a medium-bright room like the ones in our pictures, they are bright enough. However, if you have a lot of windows, you will need a TV which can get to at least 150 cd / m2
Jul 07, 2014
Is it worth investing in an anti-glare screen?
Check out our pictures of last year's 2013 plasma TVs to see what an anti glare filter does. It works well, but it reduces the vertical viewing angle.
Aug 23, 2014
I have a Sony SXRD kds-50a 2000 (green screen, therefore looking for a new TV) that does very well in my room facing four large windows and three more on the side. The only Sony TV I can find that seems to be a matte screen is the KDL60W850B
. Do you think this will work in our 20x20 room? Seems like all the 4k models are glossy screens. Am I on the right track? I have been researching this for approximately two months, and I must say you have the BEST info that I can find (that applies to me) on the web. Thank you for this great site!
is semi-gloss, not matte. They don't produce pure matte TVs anymore. Glossier TVs have less ambient reflection, but in your scenario, the more defined reflections will be more of an issue. So go for the KDL60W850B. It is a great TV.
Dec 11, 2013
We bought a Samsung LED, or LCD instead of a plasma. It is a 60 in screen. Problem is I can't see the picture from the side in the lighted room. Only when we sit right in front. We bought it because we didn't want glare, but now we can't see picture across the room. What do we do?
Samsung LEDs all have a very narrow viewing angle. If you haven't already, check out our viewing angle videos
. If you need a wide viewing angle and want an LED, you are better off with an LG TV. Of course, plasma will have an even higher viewing angle, but entry level models have a lot of reflection.
Nov 18, 2013
I find your site to be very informative, so thank you for that. I'm wondering why you don't have a section on vertical/horizontal banding, or the so-called "DSE"? It would be useful to know which sets suffer more from this, and which ones less so (or possibly even not at all, if such a set exists).
Thanks for the feedback. We will consider it when we update our test bench for next year, if we can come up with a good way of exposing it consistently for all TVs. Let us know if you have other suggestions!
We added this test
in 2014. Thanks again for that great suggestion!
Jan 15, 2014
My LED TV is placed very near a window and exposed to direct sunlight every day. A friend recommended that I always pull down the curtains, but it's tiring to do that every day. Does it really matter? What happens to the screen if it's exposed to the sun?
It doesn't really matter (except for the reflections when you are watching, of course). The direct sunlight will not damage your TV. The TV will likely break by itself long before the sun can visibly damage it.
Nov 25, 2014
We have a sunroof in the room, and in the afternoon it allows direct sunlight onto the wall where we want to place the TV. We are looking for a 55 - 65 inch TV. What do you recommend?
Sunlight directly on the TV will always cause problems, so you can't expect perfect visibility. Check out the Samsung H6350
Dec 26, 2013
I find your site very informative as well, but was wondering if you would be able to put a section where you ask to buy the size you are looking for instead of getting all the sizes priced out that you don't want.
Thanks for the feedback. We have this tool to navigate by size, but as you mentioned, it isn't very good. We will create something better.
: We decided to manually recommend TVs for each size group, for example
Sep 18, 2014
I am interested in the 2014 Samsung pn64f5000 plasma. Have you had a chance to see this model? By the way, your site is #1 in my book. Better than CNET. Great reviews. Unbiased and no fluff. Just great unbiased info. Thank You!
Don't you mean the PN64H5000 instead? If so, we haven't. It looks just like the 2013 F5300
/F5500 though. Those are great (except for the reflection problems).
Nov 10, 2014
How many hertz is a Samsung TV with a clear motion rate of 8oo?
You can convert the CMR number into the refresh rate using this table
Nov 10, 2014
In your bright room reflection test, I don't see any correlation between the numbers and the bright white reflections (max white numbers). Some have lower numbers and big white blotches. Others have similar blotches and have high numbers. Smaller white blotches have the same thing happening - high or low numbers. I know YOU know what you have tested, but the idea is not coming across. (I hate being the dumbest kid in the class, uhrrr...but I gotta ask to learn, sensei!) Are the high numbers good or bad?
You are right, this isn't clear. In the 'Average room' test, it is pretty straightforward, because the number we show is the amount of reflections. The lower, the better. With the 'Bright room' test, the number is the maximum luminance (brightness). Bigger is better. However, the score of the 'Bright room' test is based on the combination of the reflection + brightness. We will think of a better way to represent this (any ideas are welcomed).
Nov 25, 2014
I saw a recommendation that now is not the time to buy a new UHD Smart TV, because current models have 8 bit chip technology, and 10 bit chips will be introduced very soon. I don't want to invest in an immediately obsolete device. Your advice?
There will always be something new on the horizon. If you use that logic, you will never buy a new gadget, because it will be even better next year. The 10 bit adoption will be an even longer one than 4k in terms of content, so I wouldn't wait for that one.
Sep 15, 2014
We purchased an LED TV, but unfortunately, as it faced a large window, the screen acted like a mirror and we couldn't see the picture. We took it back and got a full refund. Our old TV is a matte finish, and so is much better. Is there any way around this, as we want to purchase a new TV?
Not really. TVs are now only semi-gloss or glossy. Depending on the model, though, some are better than others (as you can see in the pictures above).
Nov 18, 2014
Most TVs seem to have lousy built-in speakers. I am looking at 48-50 inch sets with clear, loud speakers built in. I am trying to avoid buying the all-in-one speaker box you can set the TV on for around $300.
Unfortunately, we didn't test the sound quality on our TVs this year. We wanted to simplify our testing process and focus on picture quality. You are right that TVs have very poor sound in general. They optimize for the thinness of the TV, which is a problem when it comes to sound. Manufacturers don't really care, though, because not only does it help bring the cost of the TV down, but they can also sell you another device.
Jan 09, 2015
I am installing a TV outside under a patio. As the temps here in AZ can reach 110F, I wonder if that will be a problem? If so, is there a recommendation?
Will the TV be turned on at that temperature? The recommended max temperature is 120F, but the TV generates heat itself so if the airflow isn't good, it can go past that.
Feb 09, 2015
I have searched the internet and plowed through big box TV stores for two months to replace a Toshiba with a matte finish or anti glare screen. None of the high tech stuff is of value if you cannot watch it without looking through reflections and making the eyes perform millions of muscular movements to respond to the picture and NOT the reflections in the room from a lamp, window light, etc. The high tech stuff is not practical. I need a simple 32 inch TV with a matte finish screen that I can actually watch for more than three minutes without eyes watering. Can you please help?
We didn't encounter any TVs with a matte screen in 2014, and it seems that companies are moving away from selling them. If you want a matte finish for your screen, you'll likely need to buy a filter and apply it to a TV yourself. Here
is a company that sells them.
Keep in mind that the conditions inside of a store are different from what you'll get in your home, so you shouldn't base your decisions off of glare you might see on the showroom floor. TVs with semi-gloss screens tend to handle themselves well in light, and are usually suitable for bright rooms.
Nov 20, 2014
If reflection is a problem, wouldn't it be better to buy secondhand "old technology," say a non-LED LCD TV? My seven-year-old LG has virtually no reflections, even though there is an entire wall of windows behind my sitting area. There is nothing I would give it up for.
If you really want a matte screen, your best option is to apply a matte film to the screen. For example, this company
makes some. Keep in mind that a matte screen reduces the apparent contrast ratio (and thus the picture quality).
Nov 25, 2014
I have a two-month-old Samsung curved TV that has dead pixels. Samsung is sending a repairman out to replace the panel. Should I insist on a new TV?
Not really. If they replace the panel, it would be like getting a new one anyway.
Jan 02, 2015
I am thinking about buying the Samsung HU9000
curved TV and have heard negative things about the curved TVs. Your comments, and should I just buy the HU8550
Yes, get the HU8550
instead. A curved TV isn't worth it and can even be worse if you sit off-axis.
Jan 02, 2015
Does the Vizio m3221-b1 have a glossy screen?
Jan 20, 2015
Love your "get to the red meat of the picture quality" reviews! A note on the viewing angle pages. Up top, the articles note a perfect viewing angle would be perpendicular to the screen, which is referenced as 90 degrees. The actual rating angle as you provide it is based on the angle from zero degrees. So you are saying that in this context, perfect is zero degrees. Your film clips make obvious what your rating angle truly means, but that 90 degree mention really throws a non-techie TV person off. To make matters worse, various sites define the angle differently. This places even more importance on each site to define/illustrate itself explicitly. You give a useful diagram, but without the illustrated angle named, it is less useful. Your description might note the angle as being the one measured left/right (counter-clockwise/clockwise) of the viewer? And change that 90 degree perfect angle to zero? Thanks for the lead-us-by-the-nose help for non-techies! :)
Thanks for letting us know about this confusion. We will update the article soon to clarify this.
Jan 23, 2015
I'm confused... in your "Bright Room" tests, you can clearly see that the H7150
's reflection of the window is very minimal. Heck, you can still see some of the TV's images through the glare of the reflected window. So when other people have asked about this very problem, why did you recommend the H6350
? Regardless of the screen finish, it seems to me the H7150 is still better. Maybe I just don't understand. Can you help me out? Thanks.
reflects less light, yes. However, it is glossy. Even if you can better see the picture behind the reflected window, the eyes tend to focus on the reflection, not the screen. If the lights come from opposite of the TV (behind you), the H7150 isn't a good choice. But if the lights are overhead or coming from the side, the H7150 is better.
Jan 26, 2015
We have a wide viewing area. Is there an appreciable improvement of color saturation and picture quality between the e70 and the m70? Is a dead pixel (black when screen is light) a normal thing, or a problem to be repaired, and a possible indication of a bad set?
No, they both have the same viewing angle issue. As for the dead pixel, make sure it isn't just a stuck pixel. Apply slight pressure to it while turning the TV on and off. This often fixes the issue. If it stays there, return your TV.
Feb 09, 2015
Well I'm finally getting my man cave/game room, and I'm trying to find the very best gaming TV. And one that has that nice smooth action feature. I think it's called soap opera, or something like that.
Are there any TVs in the 32-50 inch range with:
-Really nice picture
-Played mostly in a dark room
-Soap opera effect
Thank you so much. Can't wait to see your next reviews.
At 50", the best gaming TV is the Sony W800B
. It has great contrast and color uniformity, low input lag, little motion blur, and does come with the motion interpolation/soap opera effect feature you're looking for.
One thing: using the motion interpolation feature will increase input lag, and might negatively affect your video game playing experience. Instead, consider using the built-in "Impulse" mode while you're gaming. It strobes the backlight to help reduce blur during fast-moving action, but doesn't impact the TV's input lag as much.
Feb 10, 2015
We brought home three that looked like good candidates. They were awful from any angle. My wife said she can put on her makeup with them because they reflect so well. All the hype about picture technology, but what is it worth if you cannot view without the eyestrain of looking through the reflections? My close friend spent a bundle on one of those applique filters. They sent him a smear tool to lay it on and get the air bubbles out of it. He worked so hard on it for over an hour that he shaved off a bubble and left a huge hole in it. He got help from a sign company on the second attempt. They put expensive "wraps" on cars and buses. They did the same thing. Two filters ruined, house call from vinyl sign shop, and in the end it cost more than the TV. Thanks.
Glossy and semi-gloss screens aren't for everyone, so it's too bad matte screens aren't more available to those whose setups would benefit from them. It's true that it can be difficult to apply a filter to a TV screen, and people should take that into consideration when purchasing a TV with the intention of adding a filter. Thanks for sharing your experience with this.
Feb 23, 2015
Which is better, the Vizo M4221-B1 or the Samsung UN40H5201A, and why?
We didn't test the H5201, but we expect it would be about the same as the H5203
. The Vizio M has less motion blur, which is important if you want to play video games or watch sports. It also comes with motion interpolation capability, handles itself better in brightly lit rooms, and it looks nicer aesthetically. The 5201 does have slightly better color uniformity, but its build quality is quite cheap, and its smart capabilities are sluggish. Overall, the Vizio M is a better buy.
Mar 02, 2015
Looking for the best anti-reflective TV I can buy in my area. The closest I have available to what you have reviewed is the Samsung H6300. Is that model similar to any that were reviewed?
Yes, the H6300 should be the same as the H6350
, which we reviewed here
. It performs quite well in a bright room. If the light source is off to the side, you might want to try to find an H7150
or H7100 (both the same TV), as those have a glossy screen that reflects very little ambient light. They aren't quite as good as the H6300 for light sources that are directly opposite the screen, though, as the reflections are quite defined.