If you frequently forget to keep your old-school plastic ice trays topped up, having a refrigerator that can cool your drink at the press of a button is a huge relief. This is far from a rare sentiment: a built-in ice maker is seen as a must-have for a large segment of prospective fridge buyers. That said, not all refrigerator ice makers are alike: for instance, in-fridge setups are convenient for cooling individual drinks, but in-freezer systems are generally less failure-prone and better suited for making large amounts of ice. Beyond that, the best refrigerators with ice makers should also excel at simply being a fridge, with enough capacity to store all your groceries, no overly cold or warm spots, and well-sealed produce drawers to keep fresh fruit and veggies from wilting.