Products
Black+Decker ID1901-1BDC
Gotham Steel Air Fryer
Tested using Methodology v1.0.1
Updated Aug 14, 2025 06:05 PM
SEARCH
Amazon.com
Tested using Methodology v1.0.1
Updated Aug 14, 2025 06:14 PM
SEE PRICE
Walmart.com
Dual Cooking ChambersNo
Measured Capacity2.0 qt (1.9 L)
Nonstick Coating Type
PTFE
Dual Cooking ChambersNo
Measured Capacity2.7 qt (2.6 L)
Nonstick Coating Type
PTFE
Our Verdict
Black+Decker ID1901-1BDC
Gotham Steel Air Fryer
The Gotham Steel Air Fryer is a better option than the Black+Decker ID1901-1BDC. Both air fryers are small, simple options that won't take up much counter space, but the Gotham Steel offers significantly better performance. It makes decent-quality fried food, while the Black+Decker leaves more than half of each batch undercooked and soggy. Additionally, the Gotham Steel finishes cooking faster. Neither option offers great temperature stability or versatility, so they aren't ideal for other cooking methods like baking, dehydrating, or roasting.
Variants
- ID1901-1BDC (Black)
- Air Fryer (Black)
Check Price
Black
ID1901-1BDC
SEARCH
Amazon.com
Black
Air Fryer
SEE PRICE
Walmart.com
Black
ID1901-1BDC
SEARCH
Walmart.com
Black
Air Fryer
SEARCH
Amazon.com
Black
ID1901-1BDC
SEARCH
BestBuy.com
Black
Air Fryer
SEARCH
BestBuy.com
Main Differences for
Air Frying
Air Frying
Threshold
Air Frying
3.5
6.9
Frying Quality
2.8
7.3
Cooking Speed
1.5
6.7
Single Basket Surface Area
25.3 in² (163.1 cm²)
52.7 in² (339.9 cm²)
Full Comparison
Design
Size
8.6
7.9
Device Dimensions
Height
11.4" (29.0 cm)
11.5" (29.3 cm)
Width
8.3" (21.0 cm)
10.6" (27.0 cm)
Depth
10.2" (26.0 cm)
12.8" (32.5 cm)
Overall Volume
966.3 in³ (15,834 cm³)
1,569.0 in³ (25,711 cm³)
Cooking Chamber
5.6
6.8
Isometric Basket View
Surface Area Picture
Single Basket Surface Area
25.3 in² (163.1 cm²)
52.7 in² (339.9 cm²)
Total Basket Surface Area
25.3 in² (163.1 cm²)
52.7 in² (339.9 cm²)
Advertised Capacity
2.0 qt (1.9 L)
4.0 qt (3.8 L)
Measured Capacity
2.0 qt (1.9 L)
2.7 qt (2.6 L)
Chamber Height
3.4" (8.6 cm)
3.5" (8.9 cm)
Nonstick Coating Type
PTFE
PTFE
Cooking Versatility
6.0
6.1
Control Panel Photo
Dual Cooking Chambers
No
No
Cooking Method Presets
1
1
Minimum Temperature
180 °F (82 °C)
175 °F (79 °C)
Maximum Temperature
400 °F (204 °C)
400 °F (204 °C)
Minimum Fan Speed
2,360 RPM
2,300 RPM
Maximum Fan Speed
2,360 RPM
2,300 RPM
Maximum Power Draw
925 W
1,290 W
Temperature Probe
No
No
Performance
Frying Quality
2.8
7.3
Sorted Fries
Fry Sorting Video
Crispy Fries
21.9%
63.3%
Overcooked Fries
25.0%
3.3%
Undercooked Fries
53.1%
33.3%
Cooking Speed
1.5
6.7
Moisture Loss Over Time
Time To Reach 45% Moisture Loss
34:08
20:57
Preheat Speed
8.9
8.8
Preheat Speed
Preheat Reminder
No
No
Time to Reach 400°F
02:07
02:12
Temperature Stability
6.6
6.6
Temperature Stability
Recovery Time Once Food Added
03:18
03:19
Temperature Variation at 400°F
62 °F
82 °F
Check Price
Black
ID1901-1BDC
SEARCH
Amazon.com
Black
Air Fryer
SEE PRICE
Walmart.com
Black
ID1901-1BDC
SEARCH
Walmart.com
Black
Air Fryer
SEARCH
Amazon.com
Black
ID1901-1BDC
SEARCH
BestBuy.com
Black
Air Fryer
SEARCH
BestBuy.com
To access
and
Become an Insider
unlimited full product reviews,
product prices
other exclusive site features
Black+Decker ID1901-1BDC
Gotham Steel Air Fryer
Comments
Black+Decker ID1901-1BDC vs Gotham Steel Air Fryer: Main Discussion
What do you think of these products? Let us know below.
Looking for a personalized buying advice from the RTINGS.com experts? Insiders have direct access to buying advice on our insider forum.