Wolf Gourmet Elite WGCO150S  Toaster Oven Review

Reviewed Feb 07, 2025 at 10:37am
Writing modified Jan 17, 2025 at 09:29am
Tested using Methodology v1.0 
Wolf Gourmet Elite WGCO150S
6.4
Mixed Usage 
6.9
Leftovers 
9.1
Baking 
2.4
Air Frying 
5.7
Toasting 
8.5
Cooking Capacity 
 0

The Wolf Gourmet Elite WGCO150S is a big, high-end toaster oven. While it's not intended for air frying, it has a convection mode that speeds up roasting and baking. It also comes with a temperature probe that monitors the internal temperature of your food as it cooks. Unlike most toaster ovens, its rack guides are completely removable for easier cleaning. It has wire racks, a baking pan, and a broiling pan.

Our Verdict

6.4
Mixed Usage 

The Wolf Gourmet Elite WGCO150S is mediocre for mixed use. This model is big enough to fit loaf pans and casserole dishes. It has fantastic temperature stability, which helps you get good results when baking cookies or roasting a chicken. While it preheats slowly, it's also a reasonable choice for reheating leftovers. However, it's not intended for air frying and doesn't do a good job of making crispy foods like French fries. It toasts bread very slowly, so it's not a convenient alternative to a slot toaster.

Pros
  • Fantastic temperature stability.

  • Big capacity.

Cons
  • Toasts slowly.

  • No air fry function.

6.9
Leftovers 

The Wolf Gourmet Elite WGCO150S is alright for reheating. Since it's a big oven, it preheats slowly, so you'll have to wait a while for your reheated leftovers. However, it doesn't overshoot your chosen temperature setting, reducing the risk of your food drying out before it's heated through. It can easily fit bowls, plates, and most larger casseroles or lasagnas.

Pros
  • Fantastic temperature stability.

  • Big capacity.

Cons
  • Preheats slowly.

9.1
Baking 

The Wolf Gourmet Elite WGCO150S is fantastic for baking. The temperature inside the cooking chamber is accurate to your selected setting and doesn't vary much during cooking. It barely overshoots your selected temperature, reducing the risk of burning or drying out your food before it's cooked through. The temperature is also uniform throughout the chamber, so food should cook the same way, whether it's at the front or back of the chamber.

Pros
  • Fantastic temperature stability.

  • Uniform temperature inside cooking chamber.

Cons
None
2.4
Air Frying 

The Wolf Gourmet Elite WGCO150S isn't good for air frying. While it's equipped with a fan for convection baking and roasting, it doesn't have an air fry mode. No mesh air fry basket is included, which would help it produce more even results. While it performs a little better than toaster ovens with no fan, compared with a good oven/air fryer combo or most drawer-style air fryers, it takes a very long time to cook foods like French fries or chicken wings and produces uneven results.

Pros
None
Cons
  • No air fry function.

  • No air frying basket included.

5.7
Toasting 

The Wolf Gourmet Elite WGCO150S has a sub-par toasting performance. Whether toasting four slices at once or using its full six-slice capacity, it makes decent golden-brown toast. However, it's very slow, so it's not a convenient choice to replace a four-slot toaster that you use often.

Pros
None
Cons
  • Toasts slowly.

8.5
Cooking Capacity 

The Wolf Gourmet Elite WGCO150S has a big cooking capacity. It can fit six slices of sandwich bread and bigger containers like casseroles and 9" x 13" pans. However, the maximum pizza size you can fit inside is 11 inches, which is a bit small for an oven of this size.

Pros
  • Big capacity.

Cons
  • Maximum pizza size is 11 inches.

  • 6.4
    Mixed Usage
  • 6.9
    Leftovers

  • Performance Usages

  • 9.1
    Baking
  • 2.4
    Air Frying
  • 5.7
    Toasting
  • 8.5
    Cooking Capacity
  • Changelog

    1.  Updated Feb 07, 2025: Review published.

    Check Price

    Stainless SteelWGCO150S
    SEE PRICE
    Amazon.com
    Stainless SteelWGCO150S
    SEE PRICE
    BestBuy.com
    Stainless SteelWGCO150S
    Walmart.com

    Differences Between Sizes And Variants

    The Wolf Gourmet Countertop Oven Elite is only available in 'Stainless Steel.' Here's a picture of our unit's label.

    If you encounter another variant, let us know in the comments, and we'll update our review.

    Popular Toaster Oven Comparisons

    The Wolf Gourmet Elite is a large, high-end toaster oven. It's advertised as a more energy-efficient version of one of Wolf's full-size ovens and is indeed best-suited for things you'd do in a regular oven, like baking and roasting. Its fantastic temperature stability helps get good results when roasting a chicken or baking bread. It also has a wider range of temperature settings than most toaster ovens, so you can use it to proof dough or bake a homemade pizza at very high heat.

    However, it's not good at toasting bread evenly. If you want a toaster oven you can use as a high-capacity toaster, the Ninja Foodi DT201 offers a better performance. The Breville the Smart Oven Air Fryer Pro BOV900BSS doesn't maintain as stable a temperature as the Wolf, making it less well-suited for baking delicate foods. Still, it has an air fry mode and works much better for crispy air-fried foods like chicken wings and vegetables.

    Test Results

    perceptual testing image
    Sort:
    RATINGS
    Category:
    All
    Design
    5.1
    Countertop Footprint
    Width
    57.0 cm (22.4")
    Depth
    42.0 cm (16.5")
    Height
    32.0 cm (12.6")

    This big oven takes up a significant amount of counter space.

    8.5
    Cooking Chamber
    Chamber Width
    37.2 cm (14.6")
    Chamber Depth
    32.0 cm (12.6")
    Chamber Area
    1,190.4 cm² (184.5 in²)
    Usable Height
    16.5 cm (6.5")
    Number Of Tray Positions
    3
    Maximum Pizza Size
    11.0" (27.9 cm)

    It has a big capacity. You can fit six slices of bread and the average casserole dish. However, it can only fit an 11-inch pizza. The Breville the Smart Oven Air Fryer Pro BOV900BSS and the COSORI Smart Air Fryer CS130-AO are both smaller overall but can accommodate 13-inch pizzas.

    In The Box

    • 2 x 11.8" x 15.8" wire racks (30 cm x 40.1 cm)
    • 8.9" x 12.6" baking pan (22.5 cm x 32.1 cm)
    • 8.4" x 12.2" broil rack (21.2 cm x 31 cm)
    • 2 x rack guide systems
    • Temperature probe
    • User guides
    8.4
    Cooking Versatility
    Minimum Temperature
    80 °F (26.7 °C)
    Maximum Temperature
    550 °F (287.8 °C)
    Broil Power
    1,300 Watts
    Fan Motor Power
    23 Watts
    Temperature Probe
    Yes
    Steam Function
    No

    It's very versatile. The manufacturer advertises this model as a smaller and more efficient version of a full-size Wolf Oven, so it's meant to be a small convection oven and doesn't have an air fry mode. However, you can use its 'Roast' or 'Bake' functions with or without convection. It has a wider range of temperatures than many toaster ovens since its 'Broil' mode's maximum temperature is 550°F. The timer has a 'Stay On' mode. This toaster oven also comes with a built-in temperature probe that you can use to monitor the internal temperature of your food. This model displays the temperature on the screen, so you don't have to open the door. Finally, there's a chamber light that you can control with a dedicated button.

    Function Temperature Timer Fan
    Proof 80°F (only) 1 minute - 4 hours No
    Warm 140 - 170°F 1 minute - 4 hours No
    Roast 170 - 450°F 1 minute - 4 hours Optional
    Bake  170 - 450°F 1 minute - 4 hours Optional
    Broil High (550°F) or low (450°F) 1 - 20 minutes No
    Toast/Bagel Select Light - Dark  Depends on setting No
    9.0
    Cleaning
    Coated Baking Tray
    No
    Coated Interior
    Yes

    It's very easy to clean by hand. The cooking chamber interior has a non-stick coating, and the rack guides are removable. Once you remove the racks, it's very easy to clean the walls of the cooking chamber without any grooves or guides to worry about. It's big enough that it's easy to maneuver your hand around, and it's not too difficult to clean around the elements on the top and bottom of the cooking chamber. However, the baking tray doesn't have a non-stick coating, so it may require extra scrubbing.

    Performance
    7.0
    Max Capacity Toasting Evenness
    Evenly Browned Area
    77.1%
    Face-To-Face Difference
    71,114.5

    It makes decent toast at maximum capacity. It does a good job of evenly browning the surface of the bread but toasts the bottom face of the bread significantly more than the top face.

    7.7
    Four-Slice Toasting Evenness
    Evenly Browned Area
    86.9%
    Face-To-Face Difference
    71,719.5

    It produces a more even result with four slices in the cooking chamber. However, it still toasts the bottom face of the bread more than the top face.

    2.4
    Air Fry
    Crispy Fries
    18.8%
    Overcooked Fries
    3.1%
    Undercooked Fries
    78.1%
    Time To Reach 45% Moisture Loss
    38:04

    It's not good for air frying despite being equipped with a fan. If you use it for commonly air-fried foods like chicken wings, it's slow and cooks quite unevenly, resulting in a large proportion of not-crispy-enough food. Toaster ovens like the COSORI Smart Air Fryer CS130-AO can produce better results in about half the time. That said, it's not intended for air frying and doesn't come with a mesh basket for that purpose, which can really help produce better results.

    6.0
    Preheat Speed
    See details on graph tool
    Time To Reach 350°F
    05:58
    Preheat Reminder
    Yes

    It's slow to preheat, which is normal for bigger ovens. There's a preheat reminder so you know when it's ready to go.

    9.1
    Temperature Stability
    See details on graph tool
    Average Variation From Setpoint
    10.8 °F (6.0 °C)
    Temperature Overshoot Percentage
    1.0%
    Temperature Uniformity Across Oven
    3.7 °F (2.1 °C)

    It has fantastic temperature stability. The oven's temperature stays consistent and accurate to your chosen setting during cooking without major swings, making it easier to follow recipes and predict the oven's performance when baking or roasting. The temperature is also very consistent throughout the cooking chamber, so you shouldn't notice hot or cold spots.

    2.0
    Toasting Speed
    Time To Reach Golden Brown (Max Capacity)
    11:34
    Time To Reach Golden Brown (Four-Slice)
    09:47

    It toasts very slowly. Toaster ovens like the Cuisinart Air Fryer TOA-70 can make six slices of toast in less than half the time. It also takes an extremely long time to make a smaller batch of four slices of golden-brown toast.