Products
ExpressVPN
Surfshark VPN
Tested using Methodology v0.9.1
Updated May 14, 2025 01:59 PM
SEE PRICE
ExpressVPN
Tested using Methodology v0.9.1
Updated May 23, 2025 07:06 PM
SEE PRICE
Surfshark
Email Required
Yes
Torrent (P2P)
Yes
Data Limit
N/A
Email Required
Yes
Torrent (P2P)
Yes
Data Limit
N/A
Our Verdict
ExpressVPN
Surfshark VPN
ExpressVPN and Surfshark VPN each have strengths and weaknesses. ExpressVPN has much better security than Surfshark VPN, since the latter's kill switch leaks some data outside of the tunnel after a system reboot. On the other hand, Surfshark delivers significantly faster speeds and better latency for a snappier experience and quicker downloads. Also, Surfshark doesn't have a limit on how many devices you can have connected at the same time, while Express has a maximum of 8.
Variants
- ExpressVPN (W/ Dedicated IP)
- Surfshark (One)
- Surfshark (One+)
- Surfshark (Starter)
Check Price
W/ Dedicated IP
ExpressVPN
SEE PRICE
ExpressVPN
One
Surfshark
SEE PRICE
Surfshark
One+
Surfshark
SEE PRICE
Surfshark
Starter
Surfshark
SEE PRICE
Surfshark
Main Differences for
Torrent
Torrent
Threshold
Torrent
8.5
8.1
Kill Switch Robustness
8.0
2.0
Registration
7.5
6.1
Download Speed
5.4
9.4
Full Comparison
Security
Registration
7.5
6.1
Payment Options
Email Required
Yes
Yes
Password Required
No
Yes
Cryptocurrency
Yes
Yes
Cash
No
No
IP And DNS Leaks
9.0
9.0
IPLEAK.net Screenshot
Wireshark IP And DNS Leak Screenshot
Leak Detected
No
No
In-Browser IP
No Leak Detected
No Leak Detected
In-Browser DNS
No Leak Detected
No Leak Detected
System DNS
No Leak Detected
No Leak Detected
System Traffic
No Leak Detected
No Leak Detected
Kill Switch Robustness
8.0
2.0
Wireshark Kill Switch Screenshot
Leak Detected
No
Yes
During VPN Software Crash
No Leak Detected
No Leak Detected
During Loss Of Internet
No Leak Detected
No Leak Detected
During System Reboot
No Leak Detected
Leak Detected
Man-In-The-Middle Attacks
8.5
8.5
Man-In-The-Middle Attacks Screenshot
TLS Interruption Risk
No Evidence
No Evidence
Proper BGP Implementation
No
No
Performance
Download Speed
5.4
9.4
Download Speed Graph
Without VPN
246 Mbps
229 Mbps
With VPN
65 Mbps
379 Mbps
Speed Difference
-180.5 Mbps
150.4 Mbps
Upload Speed
5.7
9.0
Upload Speed Graph
Without VPN
349 Mbps
332 Mbps
With VPN
58 Mbps
244 Mbps
Speed Difference
-291.2 Mbps
-87.8 Mbps
Latency
6.7
7.9
Download Latency Graph
Upload Latency Graph
Download Latency Without VPN
149 ms
390 ms
Download Latency With VPN
200 ms
400 ms
Download Latency Difference
51 ms
10 ms
Upload Latency Without VPN
151 ms
400 ms
Upload Latency With VPN
210 ms
178 ms
Upload Latency Difference
58 ms
-222 ms
Combined Latency Consistency
±50 ms
±57 ms
Features
Downloads
9.5
9.5
Torrent Test Picture
Torrent (P2P)
Yes
Yes
Data Limit
N/A
N/A
Platform Support
9.3
9.3
Windows
Yes
Yes
macOS
Yes
Yes
Linux
Yes
Yes
Protocols
Protocol Results Table
WireGuard
No
Yes
OpenVPN Over UDP
Yes
Yes
OpenVPN Over TCP
Yes
Yes
IPSec With L2TP
No
No
IPSec With IKEv2
Yes
Yes
Proprietary Protocol(s)
Lightway
None
Simultaneous Devices
8.1
9.9
Tested Simultaneous Connections
8
11
Simultaneous Locations
Yes
Yes
Advertised Max Simultaneous Connections
8
Unlimited
Destinations
9.4
8.6
VPN Destination Selection Example
Countries
107
100
Countries With Multiple Cities
11
12
Server Choice
Yes
No
Split Tunneling
8.5
9.5
VPN Disabled For App Screenshot
VPN Enabled For App Screenshot
Disabling Of VPN For Specific Apps
Yes
Yes
Enabling Of VPN For Specific Apps
Yes
Yes
Splitting Based On Address
No
Yes
Ping Local Address - Same Subnet
Yes
Yes
Ping Local Address - Different Subnet
Yes
No
Headless Setup
7.0
10
Headless WireGuard Connection Screenshot
Headless OpenVPN Connection Screenshot
Headless WireGuard Connection
No
Yes
Headless OpenVPN Connection
Yes
Yes
Check Price
W/ Dedicated IP
ExpressVPN
SEE PRICE
ExpressVPN
One
Surfshark
SEE PRICE
Surfshark
One+
Surfshark
SEE PRICE
Surfshark
Starter
Surfshark
SEE PRICE
Surfshark
To access
and
Become an Insider
unlimited full product reviews,
product prices
other exclusive site features
ExpressVPN
Surfshark VPN
Comments
ExpressVPN vs Surfshark VPN: Main Discussion
What do you think of these products? Let us know below.
Looking for a personalized buying advice from the RTINGS.com experts? Insiders have direct access to buying advice on our insider forum.