VPN
Products
In The Lab
Forums
Newsletters
Join now
Best
VPNs Free iPhone Windows PC Android Free For Android Torrenting Free For Windows Mac Cheap Privacy Free For Torrenting
Tools
Compare Results Table Tool Review List Review Index Graph Review Pipeline Vote Custom Ratings
Popular
Proton VPN Free Mullvad Windscribe Free Proton VPN AdGuard VPN Windscribe IVPN NordVPN MEGA VPN Hotspot Shield Free AirVPN Private Internet Access Bitdefender VPN Surfshark VPN Norton VPN F-Secure VPN ExpressVPN TunnelBear Free FastestVPN TunnelBear
23 VPNs bought and tested
Supported by you via membership, and when you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.
  1. Home
  2. VPN
  3. Compare

Surfshark VPN vs Private Internet Access

Which VPN Is Better?

    Top
    Main Differences
    Security
      IP And DNS LeaksKill Switch RobustnessMan-In-The-Middle Attacks
    Privacy
      Privacy PolicyCompany PracticesRegistration
    Performance
      Download SpeedUpload SpeedLatency
    Features
      DownloadsPlatform SupportProtocolsSimultaneous DevicesDestinationsSplit TunnelingHeadless Setup
    Comments

Products

Surfshark VPN
Private Internet Access

Tested using Methodology v0.11

Updated Jul 09, 2026 05:40 PM

SEE PRICE
Surfshark

Tested using Methodology v0.11

Updated Jul 02, 2026 03:59 PM

SEE PRICE
Private Internet Access
Surfshark VPN Picture

Track

Private Internet Access Picture

Track

Email Required
Yes
Torrent (P2P)
Yes
Data Limit
N/A
Email Required
Yes
Torrent (P2P)
Yes
Data Limit
N/A
  1. Recommended in 1 article:
  2. Cheap

Our Verdict

Surfshark VPN

Private Internet Access

Surfshark VPN and Private Internet Access perform similarly. They effectively hide your IP address while in use, but neither has a functional kill switch, leaving some traffic unencrypted if your device crashes. Neither service has a good privacy policy or company practices, so you should use another service if trustworthiness is important to you.

GIFT THIS COMPARISON

0 

Variants

  • Surfshark (One)
  • Surfshark (One+)
  • Private Internet Access (VPN)

Review

See Surfshark VPN Review
See Private Internet Access Review
2 
0 

Check Price

One
Surfshark
SEARCH
Surfshark
VPN
Private Internet Access
SEE PRICE
Private Internet Access
One+
Surfshark
SEE PRICE
Surfshark
 
Starter
Surfshark
SEARCH
Surfshark
 

Main Differences for
Torrent

Threshold 

0.10

Torrent 
 

6.7
8.2

Port Forwarding 
 

No
Yes

Full Comparison

Security

IP And DNS Leaks 
 

9.0
9.0

IPLEAK.net Screenshot 
 

Compare High-Res
Surfshark VPN IPLEAK.net Screenshot
Compare High-Res
Private Internet Access IPLEAK.net Screenshot

Wireshark IP And DNS Leak Screenshot 
 

Compare High-Res
Surfshark VPN Wireshark IP And DNS Leak Screenshot
Compare High-Res
Private Internet Access Wireshark IP And DNS Leak Screenshot

Leak Detected 
 

No
No

In-Browser IP 
 

No Leak Detected
No Leak Detected

In-Browser DNS 
 

No Leak Detected
No Leak Detected

System DNS 
 

No Leak Detected
No Leak Detected

System Traffic 
 

No Leak Detected
No Leak Detected

Kill Switch Robustness 
 

2.0
2.0

Wireshark Kill Switch Screenshot 
 

Compare High-Res
Surfshark VPN Wireshark Kill Switch Screenshot
Compare High-Res
Private Internet Access Wireshark Kill Switch Screenshot

Leak Detected 
 

Yes
Yes

During VPN Software Crash 
 

No Leak Detected
No Leak Detected

During Loss Of Internet 
 

No Leak Detected
No Leak Detected

During System Reboot 
 

Leak Detected
Leak Detected

Man-In-The-Middle Attacks 
 

8.5
8.5

Man-In-The-Middle Attacks Screenshot 
 

Compare High-Res
Surfshark VPN Man-In-The-Middle Attacks Screenshot
Compare High-Res
Private Internet Access Man-In-The-Middle Attacks Screenshot

TLS Interruption Risk 
 

No Evidence
No Evidence

Proper BGP Implementation 
 

No
No
Privacy

Privacy Policy 
 

2.9
5.8

Privacy Picture 
 

Compare High-Res
Surfshark VPN Privacy Picture
Compare High-Res
Private Internet Access Privacy Picture

Investigation Notes 
 

Compare High-Res
Surfshark VPN Investigation Notes
Compare High-Res
Private Internet Access Investigation Notes

No-Log Policy 
 

0
6.0

Privacy Policy Audit 
 

3.0
2.5

Legal & Security Events 
 

10
10

Last Review Date 
 

2025-OCT-25
2025-OCT-15

Company Practices 
 

5.8
4.1

Company Picture 
 

Compare High-Res
Surfshark VPN Company Picture
Compare High-Res
Private Internet Access Company Picture

Investigation Notes 
 

Compare High-Res
Surfshark VPN Investigation Notes
Compare High-Res
Private Internet Access Investigation Notes

Parent & Affiliate Companies 
 

6.4
3.6

Marketing Claims & Practices 
 

8.6
5.6

Communication Transparency 
 

6.8
6.0

Security Audits 
 

10
3.0

Privacy By Default 
 

5.0
10

Terms Of Service 
 

0
0

Last Review Date 
 

2025-OCT-25
2025-OCT-15

Registration 
 

6.1
6.1

Payment Options 
 

Compare High-Res
Surfshark VPN Payment Options
Compare High-Res
Private Internet Access Payment Options

Email Required 
 

Yes
Yes

Password Required 
 

Yes
Yes

Cryptocurrency 
 

Yes
Yes

Cash 
 

No
No
Performance

Download Speed 
 

7.6
7.0

Without VPN 
 

1,061 Mbps
1,105 Mbps

With VPN 
 

242 Mbps
131 Mbps

Speed Difference 
 

-819.2 Mbps
-974.6 Mbps

Download Speed Graph  

 Preview Graph
Surfshark VPN Download Speed Graph
 Preview Graph
Private Internet Access Download Speed Graph
 Compare in Graph Tool

Upload Speed 
 

7.8
7.3

Upload Speed Graph  

 Preview Graph
Surfshark VPN Upload Speed Graph
 Preview Graph
Private Internet Access Upload Speed Graph
 Compare in Graph Tool

Without VPN 
 

1,011 Mbps
1,010 Mbps

With VPN 
 

306 Mbps
179 Mbps

Speed Difference 
 

-704.9 Mbps
-831.3 Mbps

Latency 
 

5.7
7.3

Download Latency Graph  

 Preview Graph
Surfshark VPN Download Latency Graph
 Preview Graph
Private Internet Access Download Latency Graph
 Compare in Graph Tool

Upload Latency Graph  

 Preview Graph
Surfshark VPN Upload Latency Graph
 Preview Graph
Private Internet Access Upload Latency Graph
 Compare in Graph Tool

Download Latency Without VPN 
 

134 ms
134 ms

Download Latency With VPN 
 

312 ms
172 ms

Download Latency Difference 
 

178 ms
38 ms

Upload Latency Without VPN 
 

144 ms
144 ms

Upload Latency With VPN 
 

446 ms
279 ms

Upload Latency Difference 
 

301 ms
135 ms

Combined Latency Consistency 
 

±57 ms
±46 ms
Features

Downloads 
 

7.1
9.6

Torrent Test Picture 
 

Compare High-Res
Surfshark VPN Torrent Test Picture
Compare High-Res
Private Internet Access Torrent Test Picture

Torrent (P2P) 
 

Yes
Yes

Data Limit 
 

N/A
N/A

Port Forwarding 
 

No
Yes

Platform Support 
 

9.3
9.3

Windows 
 

Yes
Yes

macOS 
 

Yes
Yes

Linux 
 

Yes
Yes

Protocols 
 

Protocol Results Table 
 

Compare High-Res
Surfshark VPN Protocol Results Table
Compare High-Res
Private Internet Access Protocol Results Table

WireGuard 
 

Yes
Yes

OpenVPN Over UDP 
 

Yes
Yes

OpenVPN Over TCP 
 

Yes
Yes

IPSec With L2TP 
 

No
No

IPSec With IKEv2 
 

Yes
Yes

Proprietary Protocol(s) 
 

None
None

Simultaneous Devices 
 

9.9
9.9

Tested Simultaneous Connections 
 

11
11

Simultaneous Locations 
 

Yes
Yes

Advertised Max Simultaneous Connections 
 

Unlimited
Unlimited

Destinations 
 

8.6
9.1

VPN Destination Selection Example 
 

Compare High-Res
Surfshark VPN VPN Destination Selection Example
Compare High-Res
Private Internet Access VPN Destination Selection Example

Countries 
 

100
91

Countries With Multiple Cities 
 

12
6

Server Choice 
 

No
Yes

Split Tunneling 
 

9.5
8.0

VPN Disabled For App Screenshot 
 

Compare High-Res
Surfshark VPN VPN Disabled For App Screenshot
Compare High-Res
Private Internet Access VPN Disabled For App Screenshot

VPN Enabled For App Screenshot 
 

Compare High-Res
Surfshark VPN VPN Enabled For App Screenshot
Compare High-Res
Private Internet Access VPN Enabled For App Screenshot

Disabling Of VPN For Specific Apps 
 

Yes
Yes

Enabling Of VPN For Specific Apps 
 

Yes
Yes

Splitting Based On Address 
 

Yes
No

Ping Local Address - Same Subnet 
 

Yes
Yes

Ping Local Address - Different Subnet 
 

No
No

Headless Setup 
 

10
7.0

Headless WireGuard Connection Screenshot 
 

Compare High-Res
Surfshark VPN Headless WireGuard Connection Screenshot
Compare High-Res
Private Internet Access Headless WireGuard Connection Screenshot

Headless OpenVPN Connection Screenshot 
 

Compare High-Res
Surfshark VPN Headless OpenVPN Connection Screenshot
Compare High-Res
Private Internet Access Headless OpenVPN Connection Screenshot

Headless WireGuard Connection 
 

Yes
No

Headless OpenVPN Connection 
 

Yes
Yes

Check Price

One
Surfshark
SEARCH
Surfshark
VPN
Private Internet Access
SEE PRICE
Private Internet Access
One+
Surfshark
SEE PRICE
Surfshark
 
Starter
Surfshark
SEARCH
Surfshark
 
Back to Top

Surfshark VPN

Private Internet Access

Comments

  1. Comparison
 • Posted 1 month ago

Surfshark VPN vs Private Internet Access: Main Discussion

What do you think of these products? Let us know below.


Looking for a personalized buying advice from the RTINGS.com experts? Members have direct access to buying advice on our member forum.

See All Networking Discussions
 Share
0 
PreviewBack to editorFormat guide
No comments yet, refresh to see new ones
We make money directly from you via Membership (which gives you access to extra features), when you buy from the RTINGS.com Shop , and when you buy a product after clicking a link to a retailer. Learn more about how we work.
We buy our own products, just like you, mostly from the United States. When a product is discontinued or no longer popular, we sell the review units locally. See what products we currently have for sale.
© 2026 9298-5266 Quebec Inc. All Rights Reserved.