Nike Alphafly 3 vs New Balance FuelCell SuperComp Elite v5

Which Running Shoe Is Better?

Products

Nike Alphafly 3
New Balance FuelCell SuperComp Elite v5

Tested using Methodology v0.9

Updated Oct 17, 2025 07:42 PM

SEE PRICE
Nike.com

Tested using Methodology v0.9

Updated Oct 30, 2025 06:18 PM

SEE PRICE
New Balance
  1. Recommended in 1 article:
  2. Nike

Our Verdict

Nike Alphafly 3

New Balance FuelCell SuperComp Elite v5

The Nike Alphafly 3 and New Balance FuelCell SuperComp Elite v5 are two popular racing shoes built around different principles. The Alphafly 3 is purpose-built for the marathon, featuring cushioning that holds up better over long distances and a broader platform that provides more stability when form breaks down late in the marathon. Whereas Nike has three different racing shoes, each built for different distances, the Elite v5 is New Balance's only super shoe, meant to be a do-it-all racer for everything from 5ks up to marathons. As such, it has lots of tradeoffs: its cushioning isn't as protective over long distances, but its firmness helps maintain higher turnover in shorter races. It returns energy more efficiently than the Alphafly 3, but is less stable, meaning that stabiliser muscles will be recruited earlier in the race.

0 

Variants

  • Alphafly 3 (Black/Olive Aura/Metallic Silver - (Men - US 9))
  • Alphafly 3 (Bright Crimson/Lime Blast/Mint Foam/Cave Purple - (Men - US 9))
  • Alphafly 3 (Bright Crimson/Lime Blast/Mint Foam/Cave Purple - (Women - US 7))
  • Alphafly 3 (Electric Pack/Olympic Safari - (Women - US 7))
  • Alphafly 3 (Football Grey/Ghost/Persian Violet/Blue Void - (Men - US 9))
  • Alphafly 3 (Football Grey/Ghost/Persian Violet/Blue Void - (Women - US 7))
  • Alphafly 3 (Light Army/Ironstone/Light Khaki/Desert Moss - (Men - US 9))
  • Alphafly 3 (Sail/Crimson Tint/Guava Ice/Black - (Women - US 7))
  • Alphafly 3 (Vapor Green/Dragon Red/Stadium Green/Black - (Men - US 9))
  • Alphafly 3 (Volt/Dusty Cactus/Total - (Men - US 9))
  • Alphafly 3 (White/Black/University Red/Habanero Red - (Men - US 9))
  • Alphafly 3 (White/Pure Platinum/Obsidian Mist/Gridiron - (Men - US 9))
  • Alphafly 3 (White/Purple Agate/Vivid Grape/Black - (Men - US 9))
  • FuelCell SuperComp Elite v5 (Urgent Red/White/Black - (Men - US 9))
  • FuelCell SuperComp Elite v5 (Urgent Red/White/Black - (Women - US 7))

Main Differences for
Marathon Racing

Threshold 

0.10

Marathon Racing 

8.5
8.4

Forefoot Energy Return 
 

8.2
8.6

Full Comparison

Design

Weight  

8.1
8.1

Right Shoe Weight Photo  

Left Shoe Weight Photo  

Weight 
 

200.7 g (7.08 oz)
200.5 g (7.07 oz)
Show Text 

Stack Heights 
 

Stack Height Photo  

Heel Stack Height 
 

39.8 mm
39.4 mm

Forefoot Stack Height 
 

33.4 mm
30.5 mm

Heel-To-Toe Drop 
 

6.4 mm
8.9 mm

Advertised Heel-To-Toe Drop 
 

8.0 mm
8.0 mm
Show Text 

External Shape 
 

3D Model Full Shoe  

Outsole Heel Width 
 

91 mm (3.6")
75 mm (3.0")

Outsole Arch Width 
 

68 mm (2.7")
55 mm (2.2")

Outsole Forefoot Width 
 

116 mm (4.6")
106 mm (4.2")

Heel Width-To-Stack Ratio 
 

2.29
1.90

Forefoot Width-To-Stack Ratio 
 

3.47
3.48
Show Text 

Internal Shape 
 

3D Model Internal  

Internal Length 
 

273 mm (10.7")
276 mm (10.9")

Internal Heel Width 
 

59 mm (2.3")
64 mm (2.5")

Internal Forefoot Width 
 

90 mm (3.5")
90 mm (3.5")

Wide Sizing Available 
 

No
Yes

Other Features  

Other Features Photo  

Tongue Gusset Type 
 

Non-gusseted
Semi-gusseted

Plate 
 

Carbon Fiber
Carbon Fiber
Show Text 
Performance

Heel Energy Return 
 

8.2
8.6

Heel Compression Video  

Heel Energy Return  

See details
See details

Heel Energy Return 
 

82.0%
84.8%
Show Text 

Forefoot Energy Return 
 

8.2
8.6

Forefoot Compression Video  

Forefoot Energy Return  

See details
See details

Forefoot Energy Return 
 

82.2%
84.6%
Show Text 

Heel Cushioning 
 

7.6
7.2

Heel Cushioning Picture  

Heel Cushioning  

See details
See details

Energy Absorbed At 550N 
 

3.82 J
3.89 J

Energy Absorbed At 1100N 
 

9.18 J
8.66 J

Energy Absorbed At 1900N 
 

14.96 J
13.82 J
Show Text 

Forefoot Cushioning 
 

8.0
7.9

Forefoot Cushioning Picture  

Forefoot Cushioning  

See details
See details

Energy Absorbed At 800N 
 

4.68 J
5.08 J

Energy Absorbed At 1300N 
 

8.55 J
8.46 J

Energy Absorbed At 2050N 
 

13.10 J
12.15 J
Show Text 

Heel Firmness 
 

5.9
6.9

Heel Firmness  

See details
See details

Firmness At 550N 
 

49.4 N/mm
58.9 N/mm

Firmness At 1100N 
 

129.6 N/mm
143.4 N/mm

Firmness At 1900N 
 

277.3 N/mm
328.3 N/mm
Show Text 

Forefoot Firmness 
 

7.4
8.1

Forefoot Firmness  

See details
See details

Firmness At 800N 
 

103.1 N/mm
103.6 N/mm

Firmness At 1300N 
 

170.1 N/mm
223.0 N/mm

Firmness At 2050N 
 

370.8 N/mm
445.3 N/mm
Show Text 

Forefoot Long Run Cushioning 
 

7.8
7.2

Forefoot Long Run Cushioning  

See details
See details

Energy Absorbed At 10km 
 

8.41 J
7.78 J

Energy Absorbed At 20km 
 

8.33 J
7.65 J

Energy Absorbed At 30km 
 

8.27 J
7.56 J

Energy Absorbed At 40km 
 

8.24 J
7.49 J
Show Text 

Nike Alphafly 3

New Balance FuelCell SuperComp Elite v5

Comments

  1. Comparison

Nike Alphafly 3 vs New Balance FuelCell SuperComp Elite v5: Main Discussion

What do you think of these products? Let us know below.


Looking for a personalized buying advice from the RTINGS.com experts? Insiders have direct access to buying advice on our insider forum.

PreviewBack to editorFormat guide
No comments yet, refresh to see new ones