The Skullcandy Indy are truly wireless headphones that have an overall disappointing performance. They have a very dark sound profile and will be better for bass-heavy music, but will still sound fairly boomy and muffled. Our unit also had mismatched drivers and the right earbud was noticeably louder. On the upside, they are decently comfortable and have a good IP55 rating for dust and water resistance, although we don't currently have a test to confirm this. These headphones will be a decent option with good value for people who want a stable and breathable truly wireless design for sports without caring too much about sound quality.
Passable for mixed usage. These truly wireless headphones won’t be ideal for critical listeners as they have a very dark sound profile. On the upside, their in-ear fit is quite comfortable and blocks a good amount of ambient noise, which can make them a decent option for commuting and at the office. Their portable and breathable design is great for sports, especially if you also use the stability fins for a more secure fit too. However, like most truly wireless headphones, these shouldn’t be used for watching TV or gaming due to their latency and mediocre microphone performance.
Okay for neutral listening. These headphones don’t have the most neutral sound profile. They have overdone bass that sound thumpy and boomy. They also lack quite a bit of detail and brightness and their mid-range also favors lower frequencies. Overall, they will sound very dark and will be better suited for bass-heavy genres. Additionally, our unit had mismatched drivers which skewed the stereo image to the right side as the right driver was noticeably louder than the left.See our Neutral Sound recommendations
Decent for commuting. These headphones are lightweight and fairly comfortable, but they might not be as comfortable as over-ear headphones for long trips. On the upside, their battery life should be enough for your daily commute and their in-ear fit does a decent job at isolating ambient noise, although they won’t completely cancel out the rumbling noise of a bus engine. They are very easy to carry around and their charging case will fit in your pockets.See our Commute/Travel recommendations
Great for sports. These headphones are a bit bulkier than most truly wireless headphones but they won’t trap heat inside your ears, which means you shouldn’t sweat more than usual when working out. They also come with stability fins, which offers a more secure fit in the ear. They shouldn’t fall out of your ears when working out, but it’s possible that heavy head movement breaks the air-tight seal which will need you to reposition them. They are also rated IP55 for dust and water resistance, which is great, but we don't test this internally.See our Sports/Fitness recommendations
Decent for the office. The Skullcandy Indy have very good isolation performance against work environment noise like ambient chatter and A/C systems. Unfortunately, their 4.5 hours battery life might not be ideal for a full work day and you’ll need to charge them during your breaks. Also, the in-ear fit might not be the most comfortable one to wear during a full day and you might feel fatigue as their bulky design can put a bit of pressure inside your ears during long listening sessions. This shouldn’t be a problem if you listen to music from time to time during your day and often take them out of your ears.See our Office recommendations
Bad for gaming. The Indy shouldn’t be used for gaming as their latency is way too high and you’ll have a noticeable delay between audio and the video content of your games. Their microphone performance is also mediocre and won’t sound as great as a gaming headset boom microphone. They also aren’t customizable like gaming headsets we’ve reviewed so far.See our Wireless Gaming recommendations
The Skullcandy Indy have a stalk design, similar to the Apple AirPods 2 2019 or the Anker SoundCore Liberty Air. They have a semi-glossy finish that isn’t as fingerprint-prone as that of the Liberty Air, which is nice. The overall design of the buds is quite bulky for truly wireless in-ears, especially if you add the stability sleeves. They protrude quite a bit out of your ears. If you prefer a earbud-like design at an affordable price, check out the JBL Tune 120.
These headphones are fairly comfortable and are lightweight. They have a traditional in-ear fit that can get fatiguing over time, but they don’t put too much pressure in your inner ear. Also, since their control scheme is touch-sensitive, you don’t have to push the headphones further into your ear canal, which is nice. They come with 3 tip sizes, but only one size of stability fins, which makes the headphones a bit less comfortable but assures a more secure fit.
The control scheme of the Indy is straightforward but slightly frustrating to use at times. Their touch-sensitive surface is fairly easy to press on, but its performance isn’t consistent. You get common functionalities such as call, music, and volume controls, on top of being able to skip tracks forward and backward. However, the procedure isn’t very intuitive for some commands. A 2-second hold skips tracks, a 4-second hold puts the headphones in pairing mode, and a 6-second hold turns the headphones off.
Sometimes, you don’t get any audio feedback and the headphones would turn off instead of going into pairing mode like we wanted to. Additionally, since the track skipper needs a 2-second hold, you need to be very fast to rewind as your song will restart. This makes going to the previous song a hassle, as it simply rewinds your song to the beginning again.
Like most in-ear headphones, the Indy are very breathable and are a good option for sports. Even if they are a bit bulkier than similarly designed truly wireless in-ears, they don’t trap heat inside your ears and you won’t sweat more than usual.
Like most truly wireless in-ears, the Skullcandy Indy True Wireless can easily fit in your pockets or in a bag. They are easy to carry around at all times, especially since they come with a small charging case that protects the headphones when you’re on the move.
The hard charging case of the Skullcandy Indy is good. It is fairly solid and protects the headphones against physical damage from falls, scratches, and minor water exposure. However, it is ever so slightly bulkier than the Anker Soundcore Liberty Air case, but you shouldn’t have any trouble fitting it inside pants pockets.
These headphones are decently well-built and shouldn’t break from normal usage. The buds are dense enough to survive a few accidental drops. They have a semi-glossy finish, which gives them a bit of a cheap feel, but they won’t be as fingerprint-prone as the Liberty Air. They are also rated IP55 for dust and water resistance, which is great, although we don’t test this internally. The case is also decently made and should help protect the headphones. The Skullcandy Sesh are slightly better-built than the Indy.
The Indy are stable truly wireless in-ears and don’t move too much when doing physical activity. They won’t fall out when you’re jogging around, but head movement might make them break their airtight seal. They also come with stability fin sleeves. While the fit is slightly less comfortable, they feel more secure inside the ears with the sleeve. Also, since they are truly wireless, you won’t have a cable in your way, meaning it won’t be able to get stuck on something and yank the headphones out of your ears.
The frequency response consistency is excellent. If the user can achieve a proper fit and an airtight seal using the assortment of tips that come with the headphones, then they should be able to get consistent bass and treble delivery every time they use the headphones.
The bass performance of the Skullcandy Indy is good but slightly overdone. Their LFE ( low-frequency extension) is down to 11Hz, which is excellent. There’s also a 2dB bump in low-bass, which means these headphones will have a bit of excess thump and rumble that is common to bass-heavy genres. The overemphasis is present throughout the range, giving the Indy a dark sounding bass that is thumpy and boomy.
The mid-range of the Indy is also good, but slightly uneven. There is a 5dB tilt favoring lower frequencies, which results in thick and cluttered vocals and lead instruments. The dip in mid-mid also means that the vocals and leads will be pushed to the back of the mix.
The Skullcandy Indy have sub-par treble performance. Their overall performance lacks a lot of detail and presence. Their response is about 4dB under our target curve. This lack of brightness mixed with the overemphasized bass gives them a dark sounding sound profile.
The stereo imaging of the Indy is decent. Their weighted group delay is within very good limits. The group delay graph also shows that the entire response is well below the audibility threshold. This ensures a tight bass and a transparent treble reproduction. However, we measured an important mismatch in frequency between the left and right driver. This will skew the sound in one direction and can create holes in the stereo image at certain frequencies. There’s also a mismatch in amplitude, making the right driver slightly louder than the left, which is noticeable. Note that these results are only valid for our unit and yours may perform differently.
The soundstage is poor. This is because creating an out-of-head and speaker-like soundstage is largely dependent on activating the resonances of the pinna (outer ear). The design of in-ears and earbuds is in such a way that fully bypasses the pinna and doesn't interact with it. Also, because these headphones have a closed-back enclosure, their soundstage won't be perceived to be as open as that of open-back earbuds like the Apple AirPods 2 2019 or the Bose SoundSport Free.
The noise isolation performance of the Indy True Wireless is okay. These in-ears don’t have an ANC feature which means they only passively isolate. They achieved about 6dB of isolation in the bass range, where engine rumbles sit, which is okay but won’t be the best option for commuting. Also, there seems to be a weak spot around the 200Hz mark. In the mid-range, important for blocking ambient chatter, they achieved an isolation of 19dB, which is very good and suitable for an office. In the treble range, occupied by S and T sounds and fan noises like A/C systems, they provide about 33dB of isolation, which is also very good.
The leakage performance is excellent. The Indy basically don’t leak, so there's no need to worry about disturbing people around with your music, even if you listen at very loud volumes. With the music at 100dB SPL, the leakage at 1 foot away averages at 22dB SPL and peaks at 33dB SPL, which is roughly as loud as a very calm room and well under the noise floor of an average office.
The Skullcandy Indy’s integrated mic has a passable performance that is common to Bluetooth microphones. Speech recorded or transmitted with the microphone will sound thin and lacking in brightness. However, it will be easily intelligible in quiet environments. However, they will struggle to separate speech from background noise in moderately loud situations like a busy street.
The Indy’s integrated mic has an okay recording quality. The LFE (low-frequency extension) of 253Hz means speech recorded or transmitted will sound noticeably thin. The HFE (high-frequency extension) of 3.3kHz is poor and results in speech that is muffled and lacking in detail. However, in quiet environments, this shouldn’t affect the intelligibility of speech and people on the line should still be able to understand you.
The integrated microphone of the Skullcandy Indy is mediocre at noise handling. In our SpNR test, it achieved a speech-to-noise ratio of about 13dB, indicating they are best suited for quiet environments. However, the mic will struggle to separate speech from ambient noise in moderately loud situations.
We measured about 4.5 hours of continuous playback on one charge of the Indy, which is about average for truly wireless headphones. This won’t be enough for a full work day, but since you can get up to 16 hours thanks to the charging case, you’ll be able to charge them easily during your lunch time. However, they do take a bit of time to charge fully for the low amount of playback you get. On the upside, they enter a standby mode after about 5 minutes of being idle to save battery life.
These headphones don’t have a companion app.
These headphones can only be connected to a single device at a time and they don’t support NFC for a quicker and easier pairing procedure. On the upside, your overall performance might be slightly improved if your source supports Bluetooth 5.0 as well.
Their latency is too high to watch video content or for gaming. It's also higher than the average Bluetooth headphones that usually measure around 200-220ms of delay. On the upside, some apps and devices seem to compensate for the delay, so you might not notice it as much.
As expected, these truly wireless headphones don’t have an audio cable.
The Skullcandy Indy are okay truly wireless headphones that will be better suited for bass-heavy music. Unfortunately, our unit had a noticeable mismatch and their overall performance is quite disappointing. They won’t be the best option and their value gets beaten by most other budget truly wireless headphones we’ve reviewed so far. See our recommendations for the best true wireless earbuds, the best wireless earbuds under $50, the best earbuds for small ears, and the best noise cancelling earbuds.
The Skullcandy Sesh Truly Wireless are a little bit better than the Skullcandy Indy Truly Wireless. They feel slightly better made and have a better-balanced sound profile, though it's still quite bass-heavy. On the downside, their battery life is almost an hour less off a single charge, and you get one less full charge from the case. Overall, the Sesh are better value for most people.
The Skullcandy Indy and the Skullcandy Push Truly Wireless are fairly similar performing headphones, but overall, since our Indy unit had mismatched drivers, the Push might be a better option. The Push do have a bulkier case which isn’t as easy to carry around, but they have an overall better audio quality and still pack a powerful bass. You also get 6.5 hours of battery life on one charge, which is 2 hours more than the Indy. On the other hand, the Indy have a sleeker stalk design and a smaller case, but might sound too dark for some.
The Samsung Galaxy Buds are better truly wireless headphones than the Skullcandy Indy. They are very small earbuds that fit nicely inside the ear and are more comfortable than the Indy. They also have a better sound quality, on top of being able to EQ’ed in a companion app, which the Indy are lacking. The Galaxy Buds also have noticeably better battery life and take less time to charge. However, they lack volume control by default, but you can set it in their app, while the Indy have that feature by default.
The Anker SoundCore Liberty Air are better mixed-usage truly wireless headphones than the Skullcandy Indy. They have a much better audio quality and their fit isolates against more ambient noise than the Indy. Their design is also a bit less bulky, making them easier to fit in most ears. On the other hand, the Skullcandy Indy have volume controls, which the Liberty Air are lacking. They also have a better sounding microphone for calls. However, our unit had noticeably mismatched drivers and overall, the Liberty Air offers better performance and value.
The Skullcandy Indy Truly Wireless and the JBL Tune 120 Truly Wireless are rather similar performing headphones, but with different designs. The Tune 120 have more of an earbud-like design, while the Indy have a stem design. The Indy have volume control, which the Tune 120 lack. Our JBL unit also had mismatched drivers, especially in the bass range, but the Indy have sub-par treble accuracy since it lacks a lot of detail, making them better suited for bass-heavy genres.
The Apple AirPods 2 2019 might offer better overall performance when it comes to sound than the Skullcandy Indy. The Apple lack sub-bass, but the rest of their frequency response is well-balanced. The open-back design of the Apple results in poor isolation performance, but it also helps to stay aware of your surroundings. They also only take about 30 minutes to charge fully, which is 4 times quicker than the Indy. On the other hand, if you listen to a lot of bass-heavy music and want to drown out ambient noise, then the Skullcandy Indy might be a better option for you.