The Insignia Fire TV is a decent 4k TV with a decent picture quality. It has a high native contrast ratio and produces deep blacks, but unfortunately, they are not very uniform and the lack of local dimming cannot help improve the appearance of dark scenes. The image degrades rapidly when viewed from the side so it is not a good choice for a large room with a wide seating arrangement. The TV supports HDR, but it can't deliver the creators intent. This Insignia TV integrates very well with the Amazon Alexa voice assistant.
Update 11/30/18: Changed the text a bit for clarification
The design of the Insignia Fire TV Edition is decent. It is made of plastic and metal but it does not have a premium look. The stand supports the TV well but there will be some wobbling if you accidentally nudge it. There are no issues with the build quality and although the bottom edge can get warm, you will have no problem with it.
The stand of the Insignia Fire TV Edition is plastic. It provides good support to the TV, although it won't prevent a slight back and forth wobble if the TV is pushed gently. At the same time, it does not leave a big space between the table and the lower edge of the TV. This might be an issue if you wish to place a soundbar in front of the TV.
Footprint of the 55" model: 43.0" x 10.4"
The back of the TV is metallic and looks very plain. There is not much provision for cable management.
The Insignia Fire TV looks thick from the side. It's just a little thinner than the Toshiba Fire TV Edition 2018.
The TV can get warm, especially near the bottom edge. This, however, should not be a problem.
The picture quality of the Insignia TV is decent. It has a high native contrast ratio that produces deep blacks but unfortunately, they are not uniform and that is not good for dark room viewing. The TV can achieve good SDR brightness levels, but they are not enough to fight glare in a bright room. The out of the box color accuracy is bad, and unfortunately, the TV does not have the menu controls to allow you to significantly improve it. The TV is made for watching directly in front, as any deviation from the center results in a degradation of picture quality. Finally, the TV can display HDR content, but the quality is only mediocre and cannot deliver the creator's intention.
Excellent native contrast for the Insignia Fire TV Edition. Blacks are deep in a dark room, and this is important in picture quality.
The Insignia Fire TV Edition does not support local dimming. The video is for reference only.
Good SDR peak brightness for the Insignia Fire TV. It can get bright enough for an average lit room, but it can not overcome the glare of a bright room. The measured brightness remains very constant regardless of the illuminated area of the screen and this is great. The SDR brightness is slightly worse than the Toshiba Fire TV.
The menu item that controls the luminance of the backlight is called backlight.
Mediocre performance on our HDR peak brightness test. The Insignia Fire TV cannot get bright enough to deliver the brightness levels HDR is mastered for. The constant level of brightness across all window sizes is good but does not really help HDR performance in this case.
The Insignia Fire TV has decent gray uniformity. Faint clouding is visible all over the screen, and the edges look slightly darker. You should expect some dirty screen effect when you watch sports on this TV. In darker images clouding is less visible, but still present.
The Insignia Fire TV Edition has bad viewing angles. Just off the center axis and blacks start to intensify rapidly. At slightly higher angles colors shift, and at about 25 degrees the picture has lost half of its brightness. You should avoid watching this Insignia TV from the side as the picture quality deteriorates rapidly.
The black uniformity is decent. You can spot some backlight bleed at both sides of the screen and around the test cross. It is less noticeable during normal use.
The Insignia Fire TV Edition has decent handling of reflections. It has a semi-gloss finish that diffuses glare across the screen and diminishes its intensity. You should be fine for an average lit room, but for a room with lots of light it will be bothersome.
The out of the box color accuracy of this TV is bad. The 'Movie' most accurate picture mode. The white balance dE and the color dE are very high and this means that most people will notice the color inaccuracies. Gamma is low at 1.93 and it does not follow the target at all, and thus shades look brighter. The color temperature is a little warm, this explains the red-yellowish tint.
The post-calibration accuracy of the Insignia Fire TV Edition is decent. Calibration was performed at the 'Custom' picture mode.
Unfortunately, the TV has a very limited number of calibration features as you can see here. These are not enough for a proper calibration and cannot help improve significantly the color accuracy.
The white balance dE is lowered below the threshold of 3 so most people will not notice any gray inaccuracies, but it is still at a level where most enthusiasts will. Unfortunately, the same is not true for color dE, where the value is well above 3 and most people will still spot color inaccuracies. Gamma is brought close to the target of 2.2, but unfortunately, it does not follow the curve. At lower luminosities, the shades are brighter and as we move to higher luminosities the shadows are crushed. Finally, the color temperature is slightly colder than the 6500 K target.
You can see our recommended settings here.
The color gamut of the Insignia Fire TV Edition is decent.
The color accuracy at our normal 75% stimulus brightness is bad, likely because the TV is prioritizing brightness over color accuracy; however at 50% stimulus brightness, the accuracy of P3 and Rec 2020 colors are vastly improved. This means that most HDR colors will have passable color accuracy, but very bright colors will be washed out.
In the Custom picture mode, the TV's EOTF follows the target PQ curve fairly closely, with some over-brightening in dim shades. If you find HDR content too dark, you can set the Mid Luminance Gamma setting to -5, which raises the EOTF and brightens most of the scene.
The color volume coverage is mediocre. The limited color gamut on this Insignia Fire TV Edition does not allow it to display saturated colors. This is very similar to the Toshiba Fire TV 2018.
The TV has a mediocre gradient. Unfortunately, it is the lowest score we've measured so far. Our image does not clearly capture the stepping in color shades that create the banding as you scan it from the lighter shades to the darker ones. This is partly because of the clipping that occurs in both the bright side and the dark side. This means that in real content, when the TV displays the image of a sky or images that contain skin tones, there are areas of noticeable banding. This, however, is more important in HDR than SDR.
No image retention for the Insignia Fire TV .
We don't expect VA panels to experience permanent image retention, as the VA panel in our long-term test appears immune.
The motion handling of the Insignia Fire TV Edition is decent. The response time is good, but there will be a blur trail in fast content. The blur helps make motion look smooth. Unfortunately, the TV does not incorporate any advanced features, like BFI or 24p Judder removal, to further improve the motion quality.
The response time of the Insignia Fire TV is good. You will, however, spot some motion blur on fast moving objects on the screen.
The Insignia Fire TV Edition is not flicker-free. It uses PWM dimming to lower the backlight. The flicker occurs at 240Hz which might be bothersome to some people.
The Insignia Fire TV does not have a BFI option.
The Fire TV is capable of interpolating content from 30fps up to its native refresh rate of 60fps.
Set the Motion Processing to 'Enhanced' if you wish to enable motion interpolation. If you find that there are too many artifacts, then you can set it to 'Smooth' or 'Standard'.
The response time of this TV allows for some motion blur that smooths motion and it is not likely that you will notice any stutter, even in older, low fps content.
The Insignia Fire TV Edition does not remove 24p judder automatically, nor does it have any feature that allows you to do so. So when displaying 24fps content the TV will always have judder. You can try to remove it by enabling motion interpolation, but this makes motion look smoother than normal and can add artifacts.
The TV has a native 60Hz panel and doesn't support any variable refresh rate implementation.
The Insignia has a good input lag in game mode, although it will fall short on the expectations of serious gamers. Unfortunately, some of the common resolutions are not supported, and you have to pay close attention to details to get the TV to properly display 4:4:4: chroma.
The Insignia Fire TV Edition has a low input lag in Game mode and while it is not interpolating. Some people, however, might still find it high, so it is not a recommended TV for game enthusiasts. When you use it as a PC monitor, you might notice some lag, especially while you move the mouse around.
During testing we noticed that although the input lag is stable, it varied slightly when we retook a measurement. The variation was about 8 ms and the value reported is the average.
The Insignia Fire TV Edition does not support some common resolutions. Also, there are some resolution restrictions, and some special conditions that must be satisfied for the TV to properly display certain resolutions.
To properly display 4:4:4 chroma you must be in PC mode and you must set the signal output to RGB, as otherwise, the TV might not detect it and might not display RGB properly.
4k @ 30Hz can't have proper 4:4:4 chroma even when in PC mode.
The TV does not pass the 1440p test, as the image that is displayed when sent such a signal does not have the correct wrapping (part of the screen's right side appears on the left side).
The sound of the Insignia Fire TV is sub-par. This TV doesn't get very loud and doesn't produce much bass, but it is decent for producing dialog. For a better sound, dedicated speakers or soundbars are recommended.
The frequency response performance is sub-par. The LFE (low-frequency extension) of 135Hz indicates a bass that lacks thump and rumble and doesn't have much body to it either. The response above the LFE point is rather uneven and lacks a bit of detail and brightness. Also, this TV doesn't get very loud and tends to produce compression and pumping artifacts near its maximum volume.
The distortion performance is above-average. The overall amount of THD produced at 80dB SPL is low, and there is not a big jump in THD at Max SPL either. However, this TV doesn't get very loud. Also, there are a couple of spikes between 1KHz and 2KHz which could make the sound of those region a bit harsh and impure.
The Insignia "Fire TV Edition" runs the Amazon Fire TV smart platform. It has an intuitive and easy to use interface with very smooth animation. It integrates very well with Amazon Alexa and there are many commands that you can execute with your voice. Unfortunately, the Amazon services and content are promoted very aggressively. Suggestions for Amazon apps and videos are everywhere and can become annoying at times.
There are no bugs on the interface and you will have no issues. Navigating through the menu is very smooth.
The promotion of Amazon services and content is almost everywhere and this can be annoying at times.
The TV has very good Apps and Features. There were, however, some issues that you should be aware of.
You can only access YouTube through a browser as there is no native app. Once you launch Youtube through the browser, it will look exactly the same as the native app on other TVs.
We could not get Amazon Video to play in HDR or 4k through our VPN. Unlike other TVs, it seems that Amazon Video cannot play HDR when there's low internet bandwidth.
The TV allows you to pause live TV using the built-in storage. By default, it can only pause for 2 minutes, but you can expand this by connecting a USB. Depending on the USB storage size, the pause time can be extended up to 60 minutes.
The Insignia Fire TV Edition has a good remote control. It fully supports Amazon Alexa Voice Assistant and can be linked with any Amazon device.
You can execute several voice commands with Alexa like, 'Change source to HDMI 1', 'Search Netflix for Marco Polo', or even 'How's the weather in Montreal'. Oddly enough, you can not ask 'What time is it', and you cannot perform commands like 'Change backlight to 5'.
Alexa is only supported on the US version of the Fire TV OS (US account with US internet connection). Otherwise, only content search is supported for voice control.
The remote app incorporates full Amazon Alexa support and works okay.
We tested the 55" NS-55DF710NA19 and for the most part, we expect our review to be valid for the 43" and 50'' models.
The Insignia "Fire TV" is also available in smaller sizes 24,'' 32' and 39". These sizes do not support HDR and have a lower resolution. In most other aspects we expect them to be similar to the model we tested.
If someone comes across a different type of panel or if their Insignia TV NS-55DF710NA19 doesn't correspond to our review, let us know and we will update the review. Note that some tests such as the gray uniformity may vary between individual units.
|Size||US Model||Resolution||Refresh Rate||HDR Support|
The 55" NS-55DF710NA19 we reviewed was manufactured in July 2019.
The Toshiba Fire TV 2018 is a bit better than the Insignia Fire TV. The Toshiba has more uniform blacks, and this is great for dark room viewing. The Toshiba also has a lower input lag and better response time which are important if you play video games. The Insignia Fire TV, on the other hand, has a better gray uniformity which is good if you watch sports.
The TCL S405 is much better than the Insignia Fire TV. The TCL has better reflection handling, so it is more suitable for a room with many light sources. Also, the TCL has lower input lag and is more responsive to your actions which is great if you use the TV for gaming or a PC monitor. The Insignia Fire TV, on the other hand, has a motion interpolation feature that will please the soap opera effect fans.
The Samsung NU6900 is much better than the Insignia Fire TV. The Samsung NU6900 has lower input lag and better response time which is great if you play fast action video games. The Samsung NU6900 also has better black uniformity which is great for dark room performance and better reflection handling which makes it a better choice for a room with many light sources.
The LG UK6300 is better than the Insignia Fire TV. The LG has a lower input lag, and better viewing angles which are great if you wish to use the TV as a PC monitor, or you have a room with a wide seating arrangement. The LG also has better reflection handling and can accommodate for more light sources. The Insignia Fire TV, on the other hand, has better blacks and will perform better in a dark room, provided you sit directly in front.