The Element Amazon Fire TV is a decent 4k LED TV that features Amazon's Fire TV smart platform with their Alexa personal assistant. It has good contrast, but its lack of extra features, narrow viewing angles and lack of HDR support gimp its versatility. It also has a lot more advertisements than the average TV.
The design of the Fire Edition TV is basic, but it looks good. It appears quite sleek when viewed from the front. The stand is quite wide, but is very stable. The controls are all located under the front, and appear more like a PC monitor with buttons for each function.
The rear of the TV is simple, and has a metallic back similar to the TCL S405. The connections are all fairly easy to access if placed close to a wall as they run parallel to the TV.
The Element Fire TV has an average picture quality. It does particularly well when it is set in a dark room since it has an excellent native contrast ratio and black uniformity. When set in a brighter room, it does an okay job too considering that it can deal quite well with reflections and that it gets brighter than its competition. The viewing angle is bad though and the gray uniformity could be better and therefore, this Fire TV would not make a good option for sports fans, since dirty screen effect is visible and the best picture quality is reserved only for a few people sitting directly in front. Finally, this TV does not support HDR but it can do a decent job playing SDR content.
HDR is not supported.
The Element Fire TV has an average gray uniformity and while looking at our test picture of the 50% gray, you can see that the 4 corners are darker than the center. The top and bottom part of the screen is also a bit darker than the middle and some faint darker vertical and horizontal bands are also visible, something that we often see on direct-lit TVs.
Looking at our 5% gray test picture, not much come out and the lighter sides are not a uniformity problem but are due to the narrow viewing angle affecting the camera since, in person, it was not an issue.
Poor viewing angle, but typical for a TV with a VA panel. Blacks turn gray when the TV is viewed from even a small angle, while colors and brightness degrade at more moderate angles. This TV is not a good fit for a room where people often view the TV from the side.
Out of the box, the Element Fire TV has a good picture quality. It is not as good as some other more expensive TVs, but it is still reasonable. The level of inaccuracy both in the white balance dE and color dE is high enough so that enthusiasts might notice it.
Those results are base on the 'Warm' color temperature, which we always use to start or review. We measured both the 'Standard' and 'Cool' color temperatures and found them to be both too inaccurate (white balance dE over 10 and color dE over 7 for both).
There are no advanced calibration options on the Element Fire TV, so the only changes that could be made are the simple changes to the picture settings that were made before the pre-calibration reading, and as such, the measurement stayed the same.
You can see our recommended settings here.
Disappointing color volume. The narrow color gamut, lack of local dimming and over-brightening of the 10% brightness colors prevent the TV from achieving a satisfying color volume.
The Fire TV has a relatively smooth gradient performance, and can show 10 bit gradients very well even though it's an SDR-only TV. Some banding is visible in the dark areas of our test photo, but this is typical for 10 bit TVs, and will pose no problems when displaying SDR content.
A perfect result on our image retention test for the Element Fire TV. After the 10 minutes burn-in scene, no remains of any of the RTINGS logos can be seen. This result is in line with other VA TVs.
We don't expect VA panels to experience permanent image retention, as the VA panel in our long-term test appears immune.
Motion performance for the Fire TV is average. The response time is very good, so only a short trail of blur can be seen following fast moving objects. The TV flickers at 220 Hz to dim, so motion isn't as smooth as some other TVs and the flicker frequency not being a multiple of 60 Hz produces visual artifacts for fast-moving objects. This TV is not able to play movies at 24p from any source without judder. The Element Fire TV can use its 60 Hz panel to interpolate 30 fps content.
The Element Fire TV uses PWM at 220Hz to dim the backlight, starting at 99/100 backlight setting. Lowering the setting shortens the duty cycle, while amplitude remains constant. Backlights that use PWM results in duplications following moving objects, but it does help to clear up motion slightly. PWM at 220Hz is unusual, and this is the only TV we have tested so far that uses this frequency. Since it is not a multiple of the panel's refresh rate, which is 60Hz, it results in shaky duplications following fast-moving objects.
This TV has no optional black frame insertion feature to match the backlight's flicker to the frame rate of the content, so the only flicker the TV has is its 220 Hz PWM dimming. Because 220 Hz is a fairly high frequency, and it's not a multiple of 60 Hz, motion doesn't look as clear as on a TV with 120 Hz or 60 Hz flicker.
The Fire TV can interpolate lower frame rate content using its 60 Hz panel. To add the soap opera effect to 60 fps content, change 'Motion Smoothing' to any value except 'Bypass' in the Advanced Options menu. Note that any motion interpolation will introduce artifacts, so use a low setting unless you really like the soap opera effect.
Unfortunately, the Element Fire TV can only display basic 4k content, as it doesn't support HDR and can't properly display 4:4:4 color. It also has high input lag making it a poor choice for video games that require fast reactions.
High input lag, even in the 'PC/Game' picture mode. This is fine for casual gaming, but any game that requires fast reactions will be more difficult than on other TVs with low input lag. Also in 'PC/Game' mode 4k @ 60Hz input shows visual glitches, and sharpening can't be disabled.
Only basic resolutions are supported. 4:4:4 color is not shown properly, even in the 'PC/Game' picture mode. 4k @ 60Hz @ 4:2:0 color is supported, but not at 4:4:4 or 4:2:2 because the TV does not support HDMI 2.0 full bandwidth. Also in 'PC/Game' mode 4k @ 60Hz input shows visual glitches, and sharpening can't be disabled.
The Element Fire TV sounds about average for a modern TV set. It won't provide a particularly enjoyable and immersive experience, but it shouldn't cause issues with understanding dialog. Any form of upgrade such as a sound bar would improve the sound by good amount.
The Element Fire TV's frequency response is below average. The under-emphasized treble region causes the TV to sound a bit dark, but it shouldn't cause any major issues with dialog. There is some dynamic range compression at higher volumes though.
The Element Fire TV runs the Amazon Fire TV smart platform, which has very smooth navigation and a great voice command feature, but pushes Amazon content and ads on the user to an annoying degree. A highlight of the platform is the Alexa voice command feature, which can do many things such as changing between apps and inputs, searching for content, and even more general purpose things such as finding nearby restaurants. The interface is also really responsive, has smooth animations and has an easy to understand layout. However, most of the interface pushes Amazon content on the user, giving tons of suggestions from Amazon Video and apps. It's annoying even if you are an Amazon Prime subscriber.
The interface has large banner ads in a few places, and pushes a lot of suggested Amazon Video and app content on the user nearly everywhere. This can be annoying even if you do have an Amazon Prime subscription.
Only Amazon apps are installed on the TV out of the box, but many more are available on the Amazon app store, such as Netflix and YouTube. However, Amazon 1-click ordering needs to be set up before any apps can be downloaded, which requires a payment method even when downloading free apps. Navigating apps feels smooth but their stability isn't as good as on many other platforms, as Netflix crashed during testing and had to be force stopped, and casting from a phone or tablet often failed on first try. The TV can play content from a USB drive, but unfortunately it doesn't have a built in media player, so an app like VLC for Fire TV is required for USB playback.
The remote is small and comfortable, and has a great Alexa voice command feature. It has very few buttons so most things need to be changed via voice or navigating the interface, but all the navigation buttons are within easy reach which is good. Holding down on the home button brings up a quick menu with settings, inputs and apps, which is handy. The Alexa voice control can do an impressive list of things, such as switch between apps and inputs, search for content, and can even do some general purpose things like finding nearby restaurants.
The TV has a lot of buttons on the bottom border, and a joystick on the back of the TV in the lower corner. When used in tandem the buttons and joystick can do just about anything the remote can do.
We tested the 55" (EL4KAMZ5517). For the most part, we expect our review to be valid for other sizes of the Fire TV.
If someone comes across a different type of panel or if their Element EL4KAMZ Fire TV doesn't correspond to our review, let us know and we will update the review.
The Element Fire TV is a mediocre TV, especially compared to the very capable competition found in its price range.
The TCL S405 is better than the Element Fire TV. The S405 supports HDR, while the Fire TV does not. The TCL is more consistent in its ability to remove judder from 24p sources. The S405 also has much lower input for gaming or for use as a PC monitor. The Element Fire TV is a lot brighter, and has an optional motion interpolation feature.
The Vizio M Series 2017 is much better than the Element Fire TV. The Vizio M Series supports HDR and has a local dimming feature that improves dark room performance. It also has lower input for gaming and is more consistent in removing judder from 24p sources. The Element Fire TV has an optional motion interpolation feature that can make motion appear smoother by introducing some soap opera effect.
The Vizio E Series 2018 is much better than the Element Fire TV. The E Series 2018 delivers better picture quality, including support for the latest HDR formats. The E Series has much lower input lag, great for gaming, and has an optional black frame insertion feature that can improve motion clarity. The Element Fire TV can interpolate lower frame rate content to help motion appear smoother.
The Samsung MU6300 is much better than the Element Fire TV. The MU6300 delivers better picture quality and can take advantage of most of the recent HDR formats. The MU6300 has much lower input lag, great for gaming, and can reduce the backlight flicker frequency to improve motion clarity. The Element Fire TV has a faster response time, so motion is a bit smoother and has less blur.